Value and Uses of TV and Video for Unschoolers

Value and Uses of TV and Video for Unschoolers Whether to forbid or limit access to video and television is a recurring topic among parents and homeschoolers. It's great to find learning everywhere! "It's not because unschooled children are superior that they won't exhibit the behaviors that parents fear. It's that their lives lack the factors that cause children to use TV in unhealthy ways." —Joyce Fetteroll "We don't live in front of it, we live with it in our lives." —"Racecar," on unschooling.info	Gilligan's Island My first TV writing: How I watched Gilligan's Island as a kid, and the thoughts I remembered years later/years ago.
	Television, Children and Making Decisions Rationally Vijay Owens' responses to a skeptical mom
	Dan Vilter's TV Page August 2003, Dan spoke on TV and learning at the HSC conference in Sacramento. Here is his outline, with some fleshing-out AND a list of links!
	The Economics of Restricting TV Viewing a professor of economics discusses this in a clinically analytical fashion
	The Wonderful World of Television presented by Schuyler Waynforth at the London Unschooling Conference, 25 July 2009
	"Everything I really need to know I learned from video games and cheesy cartoons." An account of a family's changing beliefs and practices.
	In Defense of Cartoons several families' experiences	WHAT CAN HAPPEN if little kids watch TV all day? Will they ever stop? Will they ever learn?
	The Simpsons	Unexpected Learning "their knowledge surprised us"	HOW Unschooled Kids Watch TV eclectic tastes and other factors
	A Richer Life "bursting into song" and other results of TV freedom	History of TV Links to sites and museums	Monster Mania The Werewolf accidentally captures Amy Kagey's son
	Does TV cause Violence?	WHY? Why not? Some arguments for and against TV.	Snobbishness vs. Godzilla A tale of beauty and love.
	Shared Experiences are Important	Book Worship Our culture worships text. Admit it.	What are some good Unschooling Movies? Unschoolers recommend movies to help others understand unschooling.
	Animaniacs on DVD	Television, Children and Rational Decisionmaking Vijay Owens	Magic TV Magic you wouldn't see otherwise and TV on your computer
	Do you want arguments against TV? Links to various anti-TV sites, with some of their art

"I have learned a hell of a lot through watching film and television. That's where most of my knowledge comes from, is the TV. Discovery Channel! Endless assimilating. I'm like [the] Borg. I assimilate information from telly." Eddie Izzard
voiceover commentary
on Dress to Kill DVD
"There's so much comedy on television. Does that cause comedy in the streets?" Dick Cavett
"If I can't picture it, I can't understand it." Albert Einstein
"All of the books in the world contain no more information than is broadcast as video in a single large American city in a single year. Not all bits have equal value." Carl Sagan
"If students aren't taught the language of sound and images, shouldn't they be considered as illiterate as if they left college without being able to read or write?" George Lucas

NEW STUDY
Pam Sorooshian wrote,

"I went looking for any decent studies on the effects of tv on children and came across this new study - statistical one involving 300,000 children over many years."

We find strong evidence against the prevailing wisdom that childhood television viewing causes harm to cognitive or educational development. Our preferred point estimate indicates that an additional year of preschool television exposure raises average test scores by about .02 standard deviations. We are able to reject negative effects larger than about . 03 standard deviations per year of television exposure. For reading and general knowledge scores– domains where intuition and existing evidence suggest that learning from television could be important–we find marginally statistically significant positive effects. http://faculty.chicagobooth.edu/jesse.shapiro/research/tv.pdf

OTHER OUTSIDE LINKS:

Revolution in a Box, Foreign Policy Magazine, November/December 2009

What is TV doing in the 21st century? This hopeful article says many things, including that it helps create "a world more equal for women, healthier, better governed, more united in response to global tragedy, and more likely to vote for local versions of American Idol than shoot at people."

Is "I Love Lucy" Educational? by Jan Hunt, The Natural Child Project

Don't Blame TV for ADHD Symptoms
"While previous studies have linked early television exposure to attention problems, a new study in the March [2006] issue of Pediatrics failed to find a connection between ADHD and TV viewing habits."

Little kids watch TV—alert the media! by Jacob Sollum