Understanding the Value of Principles
I saved this without keeping the name, date or place and it's been a while so I honestly don't remember who wrote it at all. And I bet the author has changed her thoughts, so it's a relic and can stand without credit. It was from some unschooling discussion in 2004, and more recent comments will follow.
The reason this conversation is really bothering me, is because Sandra kept responding with other points that had nothing to do with my one and only question. (Her points are GREAT ones, and ones I in fact agree with, but they are points about something other that my one question: Should I give my 4 & 7 year olds that particular game? She never said Yes (and why) or NO (and why). You might ask yourself if you were trying to have a conversation with someone and they were skipping over your particular question, and making lots of other points that had nothing to do with what you were still trying to talk about!!! I'm not wound up and defensive and angry. Although I find myself frustrated, and now on the defense trying to tell you (and Sandra) that I agree with all those points she made, BUT IT'S NOT WHAT I'M TALKING ABOUT. That's all.A question like "should I buy this, yes or no?" isn't the kind of questions others can answer very well. And if we did, we'd need to say WHY we thought so, which would involve explaining a principle. And with all of the best answers, it needs to start, "It depends."
If we answer questions with "yes" and "no," and give people what they claim to want, or what they think they want, we are chucking fish out instead of providing information on how to fish, how to make one's own custom fishing equipment and when and where the fishing is great. Unschooling can't work as a series of yes/no questions.
Another principle at work. Helping people learn to find their own answers is vastly superior to distributing answers on demand. And those who volunteer their time and experience are not willing to hold other's hands for years or months. They want to empower others.
Empowerment is a principle, not a rule.
Learning to examine one's own life and needs and beliefs is necessary for unschooling to work. When priorities and principles are coming clearer, such questions as whether or not to buy a particular game or tool or movie or food are EASY, simple, happy questions. That's why the mom quoted above didn't get the simple straight answer she thought she needed. No one wanted to waste time or energy sending her down the wrong path.
Rules and Principles and Math
I'm reading the first book, Shaman's Crossing, in the latest trilogy, Soldier Son Trilogy, written by someone I met about 25 years ago. (You can find her website at Robin Hobb.)
She is not an unschooler or a homeschooler, although she had four children. Her youngest is now a teen.
This quote touches on the differences between appearing to know math and really knowing math and between rules and principles:
I was good at math, but I was good at it in a rote way, just as a small child can recite "nine plus twelve is twenty-one" long before he knows what numbers are or that they signify quantities. I could manipulate numbers and symbols accurately because I knew the rules. Gord, however, understood the principles. He explained exponents in a way that made me understand that I had been looking at a map of mathematics and Gord knew the countryside of it. That is an inadequate explanation for such a subtle awakening, but it is the best I can do.
(on UnschoolingDiscussion, 11/05)
Here are a couple of examples, one very sad, in which "the rule" was followed beyond what made any sense.
We were at my mother-in-law's house and I offered to help with dishes, so she set me to dry, as she washed. The dish towel got so wet it wasn't doing any good, so I asked for a dry one. She said "Just use that one." I continued to "help," but it was NOT helping. I was just wiping a wet cloth on already-wet dishes, which wasn't drying them at all. If the principle of helping is to make things better, and if the principle of drying dishes is to wipe them dry, I was twice removed from what I had intended to do.
When Kirby was a baby, I was working with moms who had had a cesarean and wanted to (even if illegally) have a home birth or a VBAC (vaginal birth after cesarean). Part of that work was hearing people's very sad stories. A mom had been at the air force hospital here, on base, and was delivered (by cesarean) of stillborn conjoined twins. Because it happened quickly, and it was a cesarean, they had not shaved her pubic area. Because it was a military hospital and the chart said they MUST do that, they shaved her, after the birth, while she was in pain and grief, for no good reason on earth except that the rules said they would.